Indian History Battlefield Walk... “The Fighting Cheyennes” of Colorado

 

We will visit three unique battle sites in one day on this driving trip:

 

1) The massacre of peaceful Cheyenne’s under an American Flag (1864 Sand Creek)

2) A surprise frontal attack on entrenched cavalry and scouts by mounted Cheyenne Dog Soldiers (1868 Beecher Island)

3) An attack by cavalry and Pawnee Scouts against a large Dog Soldier and Lakota village that was tracked from burned ranch houses in Kansas resulting in the death of the prominent Cheyenne Dog Soldier leader, Tall Bull (1869 Summit Springs).

 

While attacks on Indian Villages made pulp novel heroes in the 1870’s the colorful Cheyenne are seldom described as mounting attacks on the army but rather as simply attacking, killing, and pillaging smaller groups of settlers and frontiersmen making Beecher Island a unique occurrence because it truly was a planned attack. Sand Creek inflamed the Plains frontier from Canada to Texas with angry Native Americans seeking revenge that led to the final defeat of the powerful and prestigious warrior society of the Cheyenne, the Dog Soldiers. This defeat occurred at Summit Springs and helped to create the legend of Buffalo Bill Cody, the famed showman.

 

We will have two nights out with the first night lodging and dinner at Bent’s Fort Inn Las Animas, Colorado just east of Bents Fort NHP (a must stop for all in-route so as to best understand the Colorado frontier of the period).    The second day’s final battlefield visit is located where we can easily have motel lodging or car camping at Sterling Colorado (or at your personal option nearer to Denver).

 

The first evening speaker is John Carson, a Mountain-man, Trader, and Trapper who will dine with us and speak about the economics and Indian relationships in the 1850’s on the evening of Tuesday May 19th  (see picture below taken at Bents Fort which is a must see as you drive in on Tuesday).

 

 

We will begin our trip with a 9 AM walk at the Sand Creek Massacre National Historic Site lead by Eunice Petramala, Southern Cheyenne Park Guide (pictured below).

 

 

The ghosts at Sand Creek will welcome us with their avatar “Cheyenne Eunice” who regularly answers questions and hears family stories from the Cheyenne descendants of those slain that cold November morning in 1864 on the plains west of the Sand Creek Indian Reservation. We will stop in route for lunch at Burlington, Colorado just before arriving at Beecher Island Battlefield on the Arickaree fork of the Republican River just west of the Kansas Border. This famous battle is well described in books by Dee Brown, author of “Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee” the Pulitzer Prize winning author whose western history output included books on “Action at Beecher Island” and “Galvanized Yankees”.

 

We will need to be in high axle vehicles only for the last miles of the trip into the Summit Springs (also known as Susanna Springs) battlefield on private ranch land where we will be welcomed by a family member of the ranch owners. This was the scene of a cavalry charge, bugles sounding and guns blazing much like a John Wayne western movie such as “She Wore a Yellow Ribbon”. The pristine battlefield is easily visualized as the Pawnee Scouts chase a courageous Cheyenne herder into and through the village. Next we will stand where Tall Bull’s lodge hid the body of the slain captive Susanna Allerdice. The speaker at a Sterling Historic Society meeting Paul attended was Jeff Broome, author of “Dog Soldier Justice” (which detailed the sad story of Susanna) one of the best books on the effects of this battle on the Kansas frontier after 1868 and the final settlement of eastern Colorado.

 

Our last stop of the day, (or if after 6 PM perhaps the first on Thursday morning) is the Sterling Colorado Overland Trail Museum across the street from our Best Western Sundowner lodging for the night (group rate at $79).  The museum has several excellent classic books of the Summit Springs Battle in addition to the aforementioned “Dog Soldier Justice” and a collection of items found in the Indian Camp.

 

Beverly and Paul will spend the day of Thursday in Denver visiting the museums and then return to Durango on Friday.

 

Paul and Beverly Dittmer will guide and Paul will lecture. Carpooling will be encouraged. Suggested reading for this trip is “The Fighting Cheyennes” by George Bird Grinnell ISBN 0-7394-0373-7, University of Oklahoma Press, 1915.

 

For those interested below are listed additional reading on these subjects:

1) ”Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee” Dee Brown (Sand Creek) ISBN-10: 0805086846

2) “Action at Beecher Island” Dee Brown, ISBN= 10: 999750285X

3) “Black Sun: The Battle of Summit Springs, 1869” Terry Johnston ISBN=10: 0312924658

4) “The Stalkers:  The Battle of Beecher Island. 1868” Terry Johnston ISBN-10: 0312929633

5) “Dog Soldier Justice” Jeff Broome ISBN=0-9742546-1-4